Thursday, May 31, 2007

The Single


From the mailbag - This is probably the most recurring question I hear throughout the year.


I bought the CD and the version is different than what you play on KTI. How can I get your version?


When many artists record CD's, they may have an idea about which songs they want to release as a single (meaning a single CD, or single track to iTunes). After they have recorded the CD, they may hear something they wish they had done - or even realize the song needs a little more "punch." Before they release the single (which may be months later), they will go back into the studio and possibly edit the song - or remix it - or even add a harmony track.


The end result is sometimes called the single version ... or radio edit.


One of the biggest out-cries I remember hearing was with Creed's "With Arms Wide Open." Early versions of the song didn't have the strings that made the single so cool.


Another change they may make is to 'rub' out dirty words or even shorten the song. I have had plenty of people ask me why we clipped the bad word out of Nickelback's ROCKSTAR. We didn't clip 'em. Instead, we are playing the radio edit.


You may ask why???? The song is obviously making fun of the rock star lifestyle and I think the words are necessary to tell the story. But we are not comfortable with the derogatory term that rockstars call the women that follow them around - and it is prominent in the CD version.


It has nothing to do with Don Imus and his use of the word.


I just think the word has no class. Milwaukee has more class than that.
As far as getting the version we play - check iTunes or visit a real music store. They usually have a CD single secion. Also try Amazon and other cool music sites.

15 comments:

Anonymous said...

The Rockstar song is a totally inappropriate song for WKTI and since there are so many words that need to be "clipped" it should not even be played - popular or not. The connotation is there and everyone knows what those words are so the message is still inappropriate.

Bob Walker said...

Hey Anonymous,

The song is a legitimate top 40 hit - and that is our format. So far our audience has really loved it.

As for connotation - the song is paiting the rockstar lifestlye in a negative. It's satire.

And it's very popular.

Anonymous said...

rockstar is the best nickelback song yet. thanks for playing it.

Anonymous said...

Hey Bob Walker

If the song is legitimate, leave the words in. It sounds LAME with the words omitted.

Anonymous said...

If the song is so popular and fits your format why are the words missing???? Leave them in or don't play it at all.

Anonymous said...

Love the song, but not in your format.

Anonymous said...

Rockstar is a song better left for the stations willing and able to play the song the way it was meant to be played, not on WKTI.

Jen S said...

How different is Rockstar from Joel Walsh's Lifes Been Good To Me? That was a huge hit and I do not have any problem letting my child listen to either of these songs. I rather he listen to them with me and we could talk about the lyrics (or lack there-of).

Face it, if you want to know the all the lyrics, all you have to do is google the song title. And, there are many other songs played on just about every station that are going to be considered "inappropriate" to someone.

Anonymous said...

Hey Bob

Do you realize there are 2 words in that song that you could get fined for? Not in the version you play but in the album cut. I just checked lyrics.com to make sure.

Pretty pathetic system we have.

Bob Walker said...

Anonymous - you get the grand prize for making a great point. I too just checked the lyrics and you are correct.

Hard to believe, but if someone wanted to complain about the lyrics - I would probably lose and have to pay an FCC fine. The words in question refer to a part of the anatomy.

I believe there is a precedent for radio being fined when those words are used in a derogatory manner (like in this song), but not if referring to a donkey. That explains why the record company "rubbed" out the words in the radio edit.

Again, that is not why we chose to play the radio edit - after all - there are other songs on the air that use those words.

The worst part - there are NO GUIDELINES on what we can and cannot let air. It will all be decided after the complaint.

Good news if you're a lawyer.

Anonymous said...

Thanks for article!

Anonymous said...

Thanks for interesting article.

Anonymous said...

Glad to read articles like this. Thanks to author!

Anonymous said...

Excellent website. Good work. Very useful. I will bookmark!

Anonymous said...

Bob,

See? WE all told you. How's it feel to go from 3rd to 12th?

Serves you right!